Picture this: in the biggest move of the off-season, Tom Brady, the 2017 NFL MVP, gets traded to your favorite team. Best of all, they gave up two second round picks and a salary cap guy to get him. This move just took your team from championship contender, to, in your eyes, the favorite to win it all.
Game one is on the road, and Tom looks like everything you were promised. He throws for four touchdowns and with the other heavy hitters around him, you start planning the parade route yourself. Now, imagine he comes back home, and throws three interceptions, and you boo Tom Brady.
Ridiculous, right?
Enter: Yankees fans.
In the off-season, the Yankees traded for 2017 NL MVP Giancarlo Stanton. Stanton hit 59 home runs for the Marlins, and was added onto a team who fell just one win shy of the World Series last season. The Yankees lineup, with Stanton inserted alongside Aaron Judge (52 home runs) and Gary Sánchez (33 home runs), in a little league ballpark, was destined to smash records and win the World Series.
Yankees fans were practically ordering the 28th ring way back in December.
Then, on Opening Day, Yankees fans were treated with exactly what they had hoped for, Stanton went 3 for 5 with two home runs and four runs batted in in his debut. Sánchez drove in a run of his own, and Judge went 2 for 4 with a run scored and a walk. Stanton was the messiah, 2018 was going to be the Yankees year.
Fast forward five whole days to the Yankees' home opener. The team is 2-2, Stanton is hitting .286 with four strikeouts, four walks, and a whopping 1.301 OPS. Yankees fans finally get the opportunity to see Stanton in pinstripes, to see what he can do in a park where the foul poles are less than 320 feet from home plate, and the walls are less than nine feet tall.
Stanton's first at-bat in front of his new fans resulted in a strikeout. His second at-bat also resulted in a strikeout. His third, fourth, fifth at-bats... strikeout. Stanton had a rare platinum sombrero in his first game at home.
So his first appearance in the Bronx wasn't what anyone was expecting out of him. But, I'm sure Yankees fans weren't worried. It was just one bad game, one drop of water in the bucket that is a 162 game season. A rational and understanding fan would just brush it off, and move on to the next game. After all, Yankees fans are known for being rational and understanding people, so that's what happened, right?
No, not at all.
In his first game at Yankee Stadium, Giancarlo Stanton, whom Yankees fans had gushed over for the three-plus months between his acquisition and seeing him in person for the first time, was booed after striking out for the fourth time, then again after fifth time.
While Stanton isn't exactly known for his strikeout numbers, he averaged a strikeout every 3.6 plate appearances over his eight years for the Marlins.
Five strikeouts in a game is not great, but not unheard of. Most of today's power hitters are prone to the strikeout, as they tend to shoot for the long ball more often, causing a dip in their contact.
Golden sombreros, or four strikeouts in a game, are much more common than their platinum brothers. Hall of Famers Reggie Jackson (or Mr. October, as Yankees fans might know him) and Jim Thome recorded 23 and 20 golden sombreros in their careers, respectively, so a few strikeouts are probably not going to be a problem for Stanton.
For Yankees fans, a superstar slugging outfielder striking out a lot is not something new to them. In the 2017 postseason, Judge became the first player in MLB history to have three golden sombreros in a postseason, yet fans weren't trying to burn him at the stake.
Something that has to be acknowledged is that Stanton is the first player in the live ball era to strikeout five times and record no hits in a game twice in one season, and he did it in back-to-back weeks, less than a month into the season. While not ideal, it's a little too early to claim the sky is falling. If you're wondering, the all-time leader for career platinum sombreros is Sammy Sosa, with four.
While we're on the topic of it's way too early in the season to boo someone, let's not forget about the Phillies fans.
Since 2012, the Phillies have failed to finish above .500, or higher than 4th place in the National League East. After another disappointing season in 2017, the team fired manager Pete Mackanin, and brought in Gabe Kapler, who was the Director of Player Development for the Dodgers.
A month before the season started, the Phillies roster was not much different that it had been to end the 2017 season. They had signed relief pitchers Tommy Hunter and Pat Neshek, and first basemen Carlos Santana, and the overall outlook on 2018 would be that it was going to be another rebuilding year for the franchise. Then, the team signed 2015 NL Cy Young Award winner Jake Arrieta, and for some reason, he was the final piece of the puzzle to turning a rebuilding team into a playoff contender, and there were now big expectations for Kapler's first season.
Having never been a manager in the MLB before, the first few games for Kapler were rougher than some had anticipated. The team opened its season in Atlanta against a Braves team who was expected to be fighting for the first pick in the 2019 draft.
Aaron Nola started for the Phillies, and he pitched well, allowing only two hits through his first five innings. However, after a leadoff double and a flyout in the sixth, Kapler pulled Nola up 5-0 after only 68 pitches. The Braves came back to win that game, and many questioned what went through Kapler's mind when he decided to turn the game over to the bullpen.
Two days later, Vince Velasquez started, and had surrendered seven runs in 2.2 innings when Kapler decided it was time to take him out, the only problem was he never had a relief pitcher warm up. Kapler had to stall while reliever Hoby Milner scrambled to get into the game, and Milner was ultimately docked warmup pitches that he needed after coming in cold, because of Kapler's blunder. The Phillies lost that game 15-2, and utility player Pedro Florimon pitched the last inning. Florimon was the tenth different relief pitcher Kapler used in the three game series against the Braves.
After being swept in New York by the Mets and fellow rookie manager Mickey Callaway, Kapler and the Phillies returned to Philadelphia at 1-4 for their home opener.
The fans didn't waste any time letting Kapler know how they felt about his first week of performance, and booed him during team introductions.
That's right, before even one inning of home play in his managerial career, Gabe Kapler was booed by his home fans. Then, for good measure, when Kapler pulled the starting pitcher for a lefty against lefty matchup with two outs in the sixth inning (the Phillies went on to win that game 5-0, and win the next game 20-1).
The baseball season is long, and one bad week in the beginning is not going to make or break your favorite team. If in August, Stanton is still striking out five times a game, and Kapler is still using relief pitchers at an unprecedented rate, by all means, make your voices heard. But, until then, have patience.
Game one is on the road, and Tom looks like everything you were promised. He throws for four touchdowns and with the other heavy hitters around him, you start planning the parade route yourself. Now, imagine he comes back home, and throws three interceptions, and you boo Tom Brady.
Ridiculous, right?
Enter: Yankees fans.
In the off-season, the Yankees traded for 2017 NL MVP Giancarlo Stanton. Stanton hit 59 home runs for the Marlins, and was added onto a team who fell just one win shy of the World Series last season. The Yankees lineup, with Stanton inserted alongside Aaron Judge (52 home runs) and Gary Sánchez (33 home runs), in a little league ballpark, was destined to smash records and win the World Series.
Yankees fans were practically ordering the 28th ring way back in December.
Then, on Opening Day, Yankees fans were treated with exactly what they had hoped for, Stanton went 3 for 5 with two home runs and four runs batted in in his debut. Sánchez drove in a run of his own, and Judge went 2 for 4 with a run scored and a walk. Stanton was the messiah, 2018 was going to be the Yankees year.
Fast forward five whole days to the Yankees' home opener. The team is 2-2, Stanton is hitting .286 with four strikeouts, four walks, and a whopping 1.301 OPS. Yankees fans finally get the opportunity to see Stanton in pinstripes, to see what he can do in a park where the foul poles are less than 320 feet from home plate, and the walls are less than nine feet tall.
Stanton's first at-bat in front of his new fans resulted in a strikeout. His second at-bat also resulted in a strikeout. His third, fourth, fifth at-bats... strikeout. Stanton had a rare platinum sombrero in his first game at home.
So his first appearance in the Bronx wasn't what anyone was expecting out of him. But, I'm sure Yankees fans weren't worried. It was just one bad game, one drop of water in the bucket that is a 162 game season. A rational and understanding fan would just brush it off, and move on to the next game. After all, Yankees fans are known for being rational and understanding people, so that's what happened, right?
No, not at all.
In his first game at Yankee Stadium, Giancarlo Stanton, whom Yankees fans had gushed over for the three-plus months between his acquisition and seeing him in person for the first time, was booed after striking out for the fourth time, then again after fifth time.
Yes, Giancarlo Stanton is already getting booed by Yankees fans in his first home game of 2018. pic.twitter.com/F5LlCzV9WQ— Aldo Soto (@AldoSoto21) April 3, 2018
More boos for Giancarlo Stanton. This time Michael Kay addresses the Yankees fans booing. pic.twitter.com/8ivtGl327A— Aldo Soto (@AldoSoto21) April 3, 2018
While Stanton isn't exactly known for his strikeout numbers, he averaged a strikeout every 3.6 plate appearances over his eight years for the Marlins.
Five strikeouts in a game is not great, but not unheard of. Most of today's power hitters are prone to the strikeout, as they tend to shoot for the long ball more often, causing a dip in their contact.
Golden sombreros, or four strikeouts in a game, are much more common than their platinum brothers. Hall of Famers Reggie Jackson (or Mr. October, as Yankees fans might know him) and Jim Thome recorded 23 and 20 golden sombreros in their careers, respectively, so a few strikeouts are probably not going to be a problem for Stanton.
For Yankees fans, a superstar slugging outfielder striking out a lot is not something new to them. In the 2017 postseason, Judge became the first player in MLB history to have three golden sombreros in a postseason, yet fans weren't trying to burn him at the stake.
Something that has to be acknowledged is that Stanton is the first player in the live ball era to strikeout five times and record no hits in a game twice in one season, and he did it in back-to-back weeks, less than a month into the season. While not ideal, it's a little too early to claim the sky is falling. If you're wondering, the all-time leader for career platinum sombreros is Sammy Sosa, with four.
![]() |
| Stanton leads the MLB with 25 strikeouts as of April 13th |
While we're on the topic of it's way too early in the season to boo someone, let's not forget about the Phillies fans.
Since 2012, the Phillies have failed to finish above .500, or higher than 4th place in the National League East. After another disappointing season in 2017, the team fired manager Pete Mackanin, and brought in Gabe Kapler, who was the Director of Player Development for the Dodgers.
A month before the season started, the Phillies roster was not much different that it had been to end the 2017 season. They had signed relief pitchers Tommy Hunter and Pat Neshek, and first basemen Carlos Santana, and the overall outlook on 2018 would be that it was going to be another rebuilding year for the franchise. Then, the team signed 2015 NL Cy Young Award winner Jake Arrieta, and for some reason, he was the final piece of the puzzle to turning a rebuilding team into a playoff contender, and there were now big expectations for Kapler's first season.
Having never been a manager in the MLB before, the first few games for Kapler were rougher than some had anticipated. The team opened its season in Atlanta against a Braves team who was expected to be fighting for the first pick in the 2019 draft.
Aaron Nola started for the Phillies, and he pitched well, allowing only two hits through his first five innings. However, after a leadoff double and a flyout in the sixth, Kapler pulled Nola up 5-0 after only 68 pitches. The Braves came back to win that game, and many questioned what went through Kapler's mind when he decided to turn the game over to the bullpen.
Two days later, Vince Velasquez started, and had surrendered seven runs in 2.2 innings when Kapler decided it was time to take him out, the only problem was he never had a relief pitcher warm up. Kapler had to stall while reliever Hoby Milner scrambled to get into the game, and Milner was ultimately docked warmup pitches that he needed after coming in cold, because of Kapler's blunder. The Phillies lost that game 15-2, and utility player Pedro Florimon pitched the last inning. Florimon was the tenth different relief pitcher Kapler used in the three game series against the Braves.
After being swept in New York by the Mets and fellow rookie manager Mickey Callaway, Kapler and the Phillies returned to Philadelphia at 1-4 for their home opener.
The fans didn't waste any time letting Kapler know how they felt about his first week of performance, and booed him during team introductions.
Well that didn’t take long ... Kapler booed on intros #PhilliesOpener pic.twitter.com/ofhwSpXgnM— Aaron Talasnik (@ATalasnikNBCS) April 5, 2018
That's right, before even one inning of home play in his managerial career, Gabe Kapler was booed by his home fans. Then, for good measure, when Kapler pulled the starting pitcher for a lefty against lefty matchup with two outs in the sixth inning (the Phillies went on to win that game 5-0, and win the next game 20-1).
| The Phillies are 6-1 since Kapler was booed at the home opener |
The baseball season is long, and one bad week in the beginning is not going to make or break your favorite team. If in August, Stanton is still striking out five times a game, and Kapler is still using relief pitchers at an unprecedented rate, by all means, make your voices heard. But, until then, have patience.

Comments
Post a Comment